Opting for cheaper Covid-19 vaccine a ‘case of penny wise, pound foolish’

Dr Yii debating in Parliament. Ends/..

KUCHING, Dec 9: Rendering the Health Ministry “penny wise, pound foolish”, Sarawak Democratic Action Party (DAP) MP chides the Health Ministry for opting for cheaper Covid-19 vaccine.

Bandar Kuching MP Dr Kelvin Yii welcomed the announcement of the implementation of the pneumococcal vaccine under the National Immunisation Programme (NIP) this year which was initiated under the previous Pakatan Harapan (PH) government.

However, he strongly questioned the decision of the Health Ministry which has opted for the cheaper PCV10 pneumococcal vaccine as it protects against fewer bacterial strains compared to the PCV13 vaccine.

“I am concern that the government will be ‘penny-wise pound foolish’ especially since our children may be deprived of a better vaccine and that it may not achieves its target to provide adequate protection for our children from all common serotypes,” said Dr Yii in a statement today.

He said 2019 WHO (World Health Organisation) Position Paper on “Pneumococcal Conjugate Vaccines in Infants and Children under 5 years of age” clearly states that while PCV 10 may be cheaper initially, but if an evaluation over a 5-year period were to be taken, PCV13 is estimated to save an additional RM 696 million compared to the use of PCV10.


“This demonstrated significant cost-saving potential as well as cost-effectiveness of including PCV13 instead of PCV10 into the NIP.”

On top of that, he said, PCV13 is the most widely used pneumococcal conjugate vaccine globally where currently it is introduced in NIPs in 127 countries with exclusivity in 120 countries, with over 1 billion doses been distributed.

He claimed that it is because PCV13 provides the broadest serotype coverage of any licensed PCV in Malaysia since it contains three additional serotypes: 3, 6A, and 19A.

“Fact of the matter, the most common pneumococcal detected in Malaysia is serotype 6A and 19A which is not covered under PCV10. PCV13 provides the broadest coverage of IPD (Invasive Pneumococcal Disease) consistently in most countries in Asia,” said Dr Yii.

He pointed out that in Malaysia, PCV13 covers 86.1 per cent of Invasive Pneumococcal Disease (IPD) vs. 62.9 per cent for PCV10 as per Institute Medical Research (IMR) data.

In Malaysia, serotype 19A accounts for 11.8 per cent of IPD, while 6A accounted for 10.6 per cent of IPD serotypes; together, serotypes 3, 6A & 19A account for 23.2 per cent of all IPD in children under 5 years and for 32.5 per cent of IPD among adults above 50 years, he added.

The sum of serotype 3, 6A & 19A accounts for a proportion of IPD that ranges from 18.0-18.8 per cent in Thailand, 19.3 per cent in the Philippines, 23.8 per cent in Taiwan, and 11.1 per cent in India.

He said there are the additional clinical impact of usage of PCV13 especially to children less than 5 years old including and listed them as below:

a) Protection of Malaysian children below 5 years against IPD isolates that have reduced susceptibility to penicillin
b) Positive impact on Community-Acquired Pneumonia (CAP) disease burden which is one of the leading cause of under-5 mortality in Malaysia
c) Significant reductions in Otitis Media (OM) after the introduction of PCV13 in the NIP

“In Malaysia, the overall prevalence of Otitis Media is 13.8, and the introduction of PCV-13 has shown to significantly reduced rates of OM episodes, among children younger than 5 years of age, as demonstrated in the US, UK, Israel and Japan, including OM due to serotype 6A and 19A.

“So, I believe it is important the Health Minister clearly explains their decision to purchase PCV10 instead of PCV 13. This includes greater transparency in the whole deal including the differences in cost for the purchase of PCV10 in comparison to PCV13, the company that was given the tender and was it done by open tender.

“This is important to make sure there will not be any wastage and that we can make sure that we provide the best coverage for our people,” said Dr Yii.