‘Voters want results, not partisan checks’: Speaker tears into DAP’s ‘checks and balances’ ploy to deny GPS clean sweep

Asfia speaking during a press conference at DUS Complex's Media Room on Nov 20, 2026.
Advertisement

By Karen Bong

KUCHING, Nov 20: Sarawak Legislative Assembly Speaker Tan Sri Datuk Amar Mohamad Asfia Awang Nasar has taken a swipe at Democratic Action Party (DAP), accusing the party of misusing the term “checks and balances” to advance what he described as “semak parti” (partisan check), rather than advocating constitutional oversight of the government.

He said DAP’s call for checks and balances in Sarawak was essentially aimed at preventing Gabungan Parti Sarawak (GPS) from winning all seats in the Sarawak Legislative Assembly (DUS), arguing that the party was using the wrong terminology in its political agenda.

Advertisement

“When DAP means by ‘check and balance’, it’s not check and balance. It has nothing to do with check and balance. It is partisan check to prevent opponent political parties from winning all the seats in the Dewan Undangan Negeri.

“What they (DAP) actually mean is a partisan check. They do not want GPS to win all the seats. That is a partisan check, but they are using the wrong terminology,” he said during a press conference at DUS Complex today.

Asfia stressed that checks and balances and partisan checks were two fundamentally different concepts, with the former referring to the constitutional distribution and balancing of powers among the Executive, Legislature and Judiciary, while the latter involved political opposition monitoring and challenging the government of the day.

He said partisan checks could take place through opposition members scrutinising the government, both inside and outside the legislative chamber, but should not be confused with the constitutional doctrine of separation of powers.

“Checks and balances mean that the Executive is checked by the Legislature, while the Legislature is checked by the Judiciary. That is what checks and balances, or ‘semak dan imbang’, actually means.

“What they are referring to is ‘semak parti, not ‘semak dan imbang’,” he said.

To explain the distinction, Asfia referred to the doctrine of separation of powers, which divides government authority among three branches to prevent the concentration of power in any single institution.

He cited Articles 39, 44 and 121 of the Federal Constitution, which respectively provide for executive authority, legislative authority and the judiciary, saying these provisions establish the constitutional framework for the separation of powers in Malaysia.

The same principles, he said, applied to Sarawak, with the State Constitution operating in accordance with the Federal Constitution.

“However, between the executive and legislative branches, there can only be what is termed as ‘separation of functions’ as the members of the executive are taken to form the legislative branch.

The same situation occur at the level of State governments including Sarawak. The advantage of having such a Westminster-style fusion between the Executive and Legislative branch is that there can be effective check and balance since the members of the Executive are also members of the Legislature and they would be subject to question, scrutiny by the other members of the Legislative Assembly,” he explained.

Asfia also referred to French political philosopher Charles-Louis de Secondat, Baron de Montesquieu, whose 1748 work ‘De l’esprit des lois’ (The Spirit of the Laws) helped shape the modern understanding of separation of powers and influenced the constitutional framework of the United States and other democracies.

In supporting his argument, Asfia cited the recent Sabah state election, saying its outcome had demonstrated what he considered the distinction between partisan checks and constitutional checks and balances.

He said Sabah voters had amply and manifestly demonstrated that the call for checks and balances at the ballot box was, in his interpretation, actually about partisan political representation rather than the constitutional separation of powers.

“This was amply, manifestly demonstrated beyond any shadow of doubt by the voters in Sabah during the last state election,” he said.

Asfia argued that voters ultimately considered the tangible benefits they could obtain from a government with substantial financial resources, rather than the political objective of ensuring that opposition parties secured seats in the legislature.

“There is no check and balance in the ballot box,” he said, adding that voters were mindful of the benefits they could reap from government allocations and programmes when deciding whom to elect.

“When a person casts his vote, he is mindful of the bountiful harvest he may reap, the colossal benefit he may gain within his reach from the gargantuan budget vis-à-vis the unproductive, barren soil of partisan checks,” he added.

He also brought the discussion to the representation of Chinese communities in local government, citing the appointments of the mayors of Kuching and Miri as examples of what he described as effective internal partisan checks among GPS coalition partners.

Asfia said the two cities had the only Chinese mayors in Malaysia, contrasting this with Penang that has been led by the DAP since 2008, where he said no Chinese mayor had been appointed despite the political parties championing checks and balances.

“These two mayors in Malaysia, the one in Miri and the one in Kuching, are threatened to be wiped out, thereby depriving the electorate of the mayors and their services in the name and for the cause of ‘check and balance’,” he said.

Asfia maintained that opposition scrutiny remained a legitimate feature of political and legislative processes, but insisted that it was distinct from the constitutional mechanism governing the relationship among the three branches of government.

He reiterated that DAP’s use of the term checks and balances to call for opposition representation was inaccurate, saying the distinction should be made clear to prevent the public from being misled as Sarawak approaches its next State election. — DayakDaily

Advertisement